How Billionaires Pay Less Than Plumbers (And Why the Fix Scares Everyone Else)

A plumber pays tax every paycheck. A billionaire's $10 billion gain can go untaxed for life. Here's how Buy, Borrow, Die works, and why the fix makes regular folks nervous.

A plumber in Pell City pays income tax every paycheck. It comes out before he ever sees it.

A billionaire whose stock went up $10 billion this year might pay nothing on that $10 billion. Legally. And I don’t think either one of them is a bad guy.

My first paycheck came back when minimum wage was $5.15 an hour. We got paid once a month, and I worked every shift they’d give me. In my head, that check was going to be close to $1,000.

Man, was I wrong. I got $540. That was it. For a MONTH of work.

I was a dependent, filed single with zero allowances, and then came Social Security, Medicare, and everything else with a name I didn’t recognize. Nobody had ever explained withholding to me. That envelope did.

Here’s how it works for the other guy. The tax code taxes income. If your stock goes up but you don’t sell it, that gain is “unrealized.” It’s real on paper, but the IRS doesn’t count it until you sell.

The very wealthy figured out how to never sell. Tax people even have a name for it: Buy, Borrow, Die.

  1. Buy things that grow, like stock in your own company.
  2. Borrow against them when you need cash. A loan isn’t income, so no income tax.
  3. Die holding them. Your heirs inherit the stock at today’s value, a rule called “stepped-up basis,” so the lifetime of gains is never hit with capital gains tax. Very large estates can still owe estate tax, but the income tax on that growth just disappears.

To be fair, this doesn’t mean billionaires never pay. Elon Musk said he’d pay more than $11 billion in taxes for 2021, mostly from exercising stock options. But the strategy is real, and it’s legal.

So some lawmakers proposed a fix. The best-known version was in the 2025 federal budget proposal: a minimum tax that would count unrealized gains, aimed at households with at least $100 million in assets. That’s about 1 in 10,000 households.

Now here’s where a lot of regular folks get nervous, and they have a point.

In 1913, the brand new federal income tax was 1% on income over $3,000. That exemption was so high that only about 3% of Americans paid anything. The top rate was 7%, on income over $500,000. People said it would only ever hit the rich.

Four years later, during World War I, the top rate was 67%. The next year it was 77%. By World War II, withholding had arrived and nearly every working American was paying.

So when someone says “don’t worry, this new tax is only for the ultra-rich,” history gives you a reason to raise an eyebrow.

There are practical worries too. How do you put a price on a private company or a farm every year? What happens when you owe tax on a gain and the stock crashes before you can pay? Supporters answer that the proposals carved out ordinary retirement accounts and homes, and that 401(k)s already get taxed when you’re required to start withdrawing. Critics answer that thresholds can be lowered later with one vote.

This one isn’t theory for me. I’m building a family compound right now, something I hope my kids inherit someday. Under today’s rules, they’d likely owe nothing on it. Inherited property gets that stepped-up basis, and the federal estate tax only starts above $15 million per person.

But in 2021, a proposal would have ended the step-up for gains over $1 million per person. Supporters said only about 3% of households have gains that big, and that family farms and businesses would be protected while the family kept running them. Farm groups answered that land prices had climbed so much that about a third of farms were already over that line. Congress left it out of the final bill. But it was on the table.

So when I hear “this only hits the ultra-rich,” I think about my kids owing tax on land I gave them and never sold.

I’m not going to tell you how to vote. I just think both of these are true at the same time:

  • The system lets the richest people grow wealth almost tax-free for life.
  • Taxes that start “only on the rich” have a history of not staying there.

The story under the story: the fight isn’t really rich versus everybody else. It’s about whether you trust the rule to stay where they say it’ll stay.

Comments: keep it kind. What would a fair fix look like to you?