Back in my day, a pizza was basically five bucks. You could get a Domino’s pizza or a Subway footlong, and either way that was dinner. Domino’s Mix & Match deal launched in 2009 at $5.99 for a medium two-topping, and the price didn’t budge for 13 years. Through a recession, a pandemic, and a lot of Super Bowls.
Then in 2022 it finally went to $6.99. Delivery went up in March. Carryout held out until October.
Why carryout held on longer is the whole story. But first, a confession.
I used to be a general manager at Domino’s, so I’ve seen this one from behind the counter.
Here’s what I learned behind that counter: the deal doesn’t have to make much money. The order does.
Nobody walks in, buys one $6.99 pizza, and leaves. You get two, because the deal says “pick two.” Then somebody wants bread twists. Somebody wants a soda. Your kid sees the lava cakes. The pizza got you in the door. Everything else paid the light bill.
Economists call this a loss leader, or at least a low-margin leader. Grocery stores do it with milk at the back of the store. Domino’s does it with a pizza price you can remember without trying.
When I was a GM, I ran the easiest contest in the world. Sell the most cheesy bread, win $50. The only catch: you had to beat me.
I worked the most hours in the building, but I didn’t take the most orders. Didn’t matter. My crew went nuts. Every single order got the offer. If you walked past my store to drop your kids off at the gymnastics studio next door, you got offered cheesy bread.
The secret? It was an easy sell. $3.99, and who doesn’t love cheesy bread? That’s the whole model in one item. The pizza price gets you in the door. The easy $3.99 yes is what makes the night worth it.
Now back to carryout. In 2022, Domino’s couldn’t find enough delivery drivers. A delivered pizza needs a person, a car, gas, and insurance. A carryout pizza needs you. So the company kept carryout cheaper for longer, and even ran a promo that gave customers a $3 coupon for picking up their own order. They literally tipped you for being your own driver.
Around the same time, the $7.99 carryout deal quietly shrank. The wings went from 10 pieces to 8, and the deal went online-only. Online-only means fewer employees answering phones. (Yes, this is the same economics as my hold music post. Labor is always the big number.)
One honest note: Domino’s doesn’t publish what it makes on a single deal pizza, so I can’t tell you the exact margin. But you can see the strategy in the moves. When drivers got scarce, delivery got pricier. When phones cost too much, the deal moved to the app.
So the next time you pay $6.99 for a pizza, know what you really bought. You bought a ticket into a building, or an app, built to sell you a lava cake.
The story under the story: the cheap thing exists to sell you the expensive thing.
Comments: what’s the one add-on you can never say no to?